BugWP logo BugWP
Back to Community
Home / Community / Plugin → Woocommerce tax (formerly woocommerce shipping & tax)

Why Your WooCommerce Tax Isn't Calculating Correctly (And How to Fix It)

42 threads Sep 16, 2025 Plugin → Woocommerce tax (formerly woocommerce shipping & tax)

Content

Understanding WooCommerce Tax Calculation Issues

Many WooCommerce store owners rely on the WooCommerce Tax plugin (formerly WooCommerce Shipping & Tax) for automated tax calculations. However, numerous users report issues where taxes don't appear, calculate incorrectly, or disappear under certain conditions. Based on community reports, here are the most common problems and their solutions.

Common Tax Calculation Issues and Solutions

1. Automated Taxes Not Showing for Certain Locations

Problem: Taxes don't calculate for customers in specific states or countries, even when they should be taxable.

Why it happens: WooCommerce Tax uses your store address (set in WooCommerce > Settings > General) as your single "tax nexus." This means it only automatically collects sales tax for customers in locations where you have a physical presence (nexus). If your business has expanded to other states where you now have nexus, the automated system may not account for this.

Solution: Verify your store address is correct in WooCommerce settings. If you need to collect tax in multiple states, you may need to implement manual tax rates for additional nexus locations alongside the automated system.

2. Tax Not Calculating on Shipping

Problem: Even when shipping is marked as taxable, no tax is applied to shipping costs.

Why it happens: With automated taxes enabled, whether shipping is taxed is determined by TaxJar's API based on local tax laws, not by your WooCommerce settings. The plugin fetches this information automatically and you cannot manually override it when using automated calculations.

Solution: If you're using manual tax rates, ensure the "Shipping" checkbox is ticked in WooCommerce > Settings > Tax > Standard Rates. For automated taxes, you cannot change this behavior—the taxability of shipping is determined by the tax API.

3. Tax Disappears When Changing Shipping Methods

Problem: Tax calculations change or disappear entirely when customers select different shipping methods.

Why it happens: Some shipping methods, particularly local pickup, can affect tax calculations differently than shipped orders based on local tax regulations. Additionally, caching issues can sometimes interfere with tax recalculations.

Solution: Exclude cart, checkout, and account pages from any caching systems. Test with all caching disabled to see if this resolves the issue. Also verify that your tax settings are consistent across all shipping methods.

4. Tax Shows $0 for Logged-out Users

Problem: Taxes calculate correctly for logged-in users but show as $0 for visitors.

Why it happens: This is typically a caching issue. Many caching systems are disabled for logged-in users, which explains why the problem only affects visitors.

Solution: Ensure your cart, checkout, and account pages are excluded from all caching mechanisms, including any host-level caching. Test with caching completely disabled to confirm this resolves the issue.

5. Tax Calculations Inconsistent or Randomly Disappearing

Problem: Taxes work sometimes but not others, with no apparent pattern.

Why it happens: This could be caused by conflicting tax settings, outdated tax tables, or issues with the tax calculation API connection.

Solution: First, ensure you're not using both automated and manual tax rates simultaneously—this can cause conflicts. Clear old tax rates if you've switched from manual to automated calculations. Check your system status for any API connection errors with the tax service.

Important Limitations to Understand

The WooCommerce Tax plugin has several important limitations that users should be aware of:

  • It only supports one tax nexus (your store address)
  • You cannot set minimum order amounts for tax application
  • Shipping taxability is determined by the API, not your settings
  • It doesn't support pro-rated shipping taxes for mixed cart items
  • The tax rate percentage isn't displayed by default on checkout

When to Seek Additional Help

If you've tried these solutions and still experience issues, consider:

  1. Consulting with a tax professional to ensure you're collecting the correct taxes for your business situation
  2. Checking the TaxJar demo tool to verify what taxes should be collected for specific addresses
  3. Testing with a default theme and only WooCommerce and WooCommerce Tax plugins active to rule out conflicts

Remember that while WooCommerce Tax automates calculations, ultimately you're responsible for ensuring proper tax collection based on your business's specific circumstances and locations.

Related Support Threads Support