Back to Community
Home / Community / Plugin → Woocommerce tax (formerly woocommerce shipping & tax)

Why Your WooCommerce Shipping Costs Double When Adding Multiple Items (And How to Fix It)

39 threads Sep 11, 2025 Plugin → Woocommerce tax (formerly woocommerce shipping & tax)

Content

One of the most common and frustrating issues reported by store owners using WooCommerce Tax (formerly WooCommerce Shipping & Tax) is shipping costs that incorrectly double or multiply when customers add more than one item to their cart. Instead of a marginal increase for combined packaging, the system charges as if each item is in its own separate box, leading to wildly inflated and inaccurate quotes that can drive customers away.

Why This Happens

This problem is not typically a bug, but rather a fundamental aspect of how the plugin's packaging logic is configured. Based on numerous community reports, the issue almost always stems from one of two settings:

  1. Packaging Configuration: The core of the issue lies in the 'Parcel Packing Method' found in the shipping service's settings (e.g., under WooCommerce > Settings > Shipping > USPS). If this is set to 'Pack items individually,' the plugin will calculate a shipping rate for every single item in the cart, causing costs to multiply.
  2. Box Packing Logic: Even when not packing individually, the plugin's algorithm must determine how to combine items into your predefined boxes. If your products' dimensions are not set, are inaccurate, or if your predefined boxes are too small, the logic may fail to combine items and will instead create multiple packages.

How to Fix It: Step-by-Step Solutions

Solution 1: Configure the Parcel Packing Method

The first and most crucial step is to check your packing method setting.

  1. Navigate to WooCommerce > Settings > Shipping.
  2. Click on the shipping service you are using (e.g., USPS (WooCommerce Services) or Canada Post).
  3. Find the option for 'Parcel Packing Method'.
  4. Ensure it is set to 'Pack into boxes with weights and dimensions' (or a similar 'Pack together' option) and NOT 'Pack items individually'.
  5. Save your changes and clear any caching on your site.

Solution 2: Define Your Shipping Boxes

For the 'pack together' logic to work, the plugin needs to know what boxes you have available. You must define these in the Packaging Manager.

  1. In your shipping service's settings, look for a 'Packaging' or 'Packaging Manager' section.
  2. Add every box, envelope, or mailer you use for shipping. Accurately input their inner dimensions and maximum weight capacity.
  3. Save these packages. The plugin will now attempt to intelligently fit products into these boxes.

Solution 3: Verify Product Dimensions and Weight

The packaging algorithm cannot work without accurate data. Every single physical product in your store must have correct weight and dimensions entered in its shipping settings. Double-check these values; if they are missing or wrong, the plugin cannot calculate properly.

Solution 4: Understand Flat Rate vs. Weight-Based Services

It's important to note that some services, like USPS Flat Rate boxes, charge by the box, not by weight. As confirmed in community threads, if a product fits in a Flat Rate box, the cost is fixed. Adding a second item that forces the use of a second Flat Rate box will correctly double the cost. This is the intended behavior for Flat Rate services, not an error.

When the Problem Persists

If you have confirmed all settings are correct but are still experiencing issues, the problem may be due to a conflict with another plugin or your theme.

  1. Perform a conflict test by temporarily disabling all other plugins except WooCommerce and WooCommerce Tax, and switching to a default theme like Storefront.
  2. Test the shipping calculation again. If it works, reactivate your plugins one-by-one to identify the culprit.

By methodically working through these configuration settings, most store owners can resolve the issue of multiplying shipping costs and ensure their customers are presented with accurate, fair rates.

Related Support Threads Support