BugWP logo BugWP
Back to Community
Home / Community / Plugin → Autoptimize

Why Autoptimize Might Lower Your PageSpeed Score (And How to Fix It)

31 threads Sep 7, 2025 Plugin → Autoptimize

Content

It's a frustrating scenario: you install a performance plugin like Autoptimize expecting a speed boost, only to find your Google PageSpeed Insights score has dropped. Based on numerous community reports, this is a common experience, but it's almost always solvable. This guide will walk you through the typical reasons why this happens and the steps you can take to get your site's performance back on track.

Why Would a Speed Plugin Slow My Site Down?

Autoptimize works by restructuring your site's code. This process is highly dependent on your specific theme, plugins, and configuration. A setting that works wonders for one site can break another. The drop in score isn't usually the plugin itself slowing things down, but rather an unintended side effect of how it's interacting with your site's unique setup.

Common Causes and Their Solutions

1. Render-Blocking CSS

The Problem: One of the most frequent issues is that Autoptimize's aggregated CSS file becomes a new render-blocking resource. PageSpeed Insights will flag this, suggesting you "Eliminate render-blocking resources," which can hurt your score.

The Solution: Enable the "Inline and Defer CSS" option. This is a powerful feature that can significantly improve performance. To use it correctly, you must provide the critical CSS needed to style the above-the-fold content. You can do this by:

  • Using the integrated CriticalCSS.com service (a paid, third-party API).
  • Manually generating and pasting critical CSS into the field provided.
  • Creating manual rules on the Critical CSS tab for different page types.

2. JavaScript Conflicts and Broken Functionality

The Problem: Aggregating and deferring JavaScript can break interactive elements like sliders, menus, or popups. When you see a high score but a broken website, JavaScript is the likely culprit.

The Solution: Troubleshoot systematically. First, check your browser's console (F12) for JavaScript errors when the problematic settings are active. This will point you to the failing script. Often, the solution is to add specific scripts to the "Exclude scripts from optimization" field in Autoptimize's settings. Common exclusions include js/jquery/jquery.js (or jquery-min.js) and scripts from specific plugins that are known to be fragile.

3. Lack of Page Caching

The Problem: Autoptimize performs its optimizations on-the-fly, which can increase the Time to First Byte (TTFB) as WordPress processes the requests. Without a page cache, this overhead is incurred on every page load, negating the benefits of the optimized files.

The Solution: This is non-negotiable: always use Autoptimize with a page caching plugin. The cache stores the fully optimized HTML, so the optimization process only happens once. Popular options include WP Super Cache, Cache Enabler, or WP Rocket. Many reported performance issues are resolved simply by activating a page cache.

4. Incorrect Critical CSS

The Problem: If you are using the "Inline and Defer CSS" option but the critical CSS is incorrect or too short, it can cause a dramatic increase in metrics like Total Blocking Time (TBT) and Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS), crushing your mobile score.

The Solution: Double-check your critical CSS. Ensure it is comprehensive enough to style all content visible when the page first loads. If using a service, try regenerating the CSS. If entering it manually, review it for completeness.

5. Optimizing Third-Party Code

The Problem: PageSpeed might report that Autoptimize's files contain "unused code" or are too large. It's important to understand that Autoptimize is aggregating code from your theme and all your plugins. The "bloat" originates from there, not from Autoptimize itself.

The Solution: To tackle unused code, look at the source: your theme and plugins. Consider using a plugin like Plugin Organizer to load plugins only on the pages where they are needed. For unused CSS, third-party services like Rapidload can help.

Troubleshooting Checklist

  1. Isolate the Issue: Turn off all Autoptimize settings. Then, enable them one by one (JavaScript, CSS, HTML, Images) while testing your site's functionality and score after each change. This will identify which optimization is causing the problem.
  2. Clear All Caches: After every configuration change, clear Autoptimize's cache, your page cache, and your browser cache before retesting.
  3. Read the Error Messages: Don't just look at the overall score. Read PageSpeed Insights' "Opportunities" and "Diagnostics" sections. They provide specific, actionable clues on what to fix next.
  4. Test Real Performance: Use tools like WebPageTest.org for more detailed metrics than PageSpeed Insights alone can provide. Sometimes a change that drops your score by a few points might actually improve real-world loading perception.

Remember, optimization is a process of trial and error. What works for one site may not work for another. By methodically testing configurations and understanding the common pitfalls, you can configure Autoptimize to deliver the significant speed improvements it's capable of.

Related Support Threads Support