BugWP logo BugWP
Back to Community
Home / Community / Plugin → Members – membership & user role editor plugin

Understanding and Managing User Roles Across a WordPress Multisite Network

18 threads Sep 7, 2025 Plugin → Members – membership & user role editor plugin

Content

Managing user roles and capabilities consistently across a WordPress Multisite network is a common challenge. Users often expect that a role created on one subsite will automatically be available and identical on all others. This article explains the core WordPress behavior that causes this and outlines the most common solutions.

The Core Challenge: How WordPress Stores Roles

The fundamental reason for role management challenges in Multisite lies in how WordPress is designed. Unlike users, who are stored in network-wide database tables, user roles and their capabilities are stored in the wp_options table of each individual subsite (specifically in the wp_*_user_roles option, where * is the subsite's ID).

This means:

  • A custom role created on Subsite A exists only in the database for Subsite A.
  • Subsite B has its own completely separate set of roles and capabilities.
  • There is no built-in mechanism in WordPress or the Members plugin to automatically synchronize these roles across the network.

This design leads to several frequently reported scenarios:

  • A role appears on a subsite but its display name is blank.
  • Attempting to edit a role on a subsite results in an error like "The requested role to edit does not exist."
  • Capabilities granted by other plugins (e.g., WooCommerce, WPCode) may appear for a role on one subsite but not another, especially if those plugins are not active on all subsites.
  • Users added to a subsite may not receive a role if there is a conflict during the assignment process.

Common Solutions and Workarounds

Since the plugin does not include a native role synchronization feature, achieving consistency requires alternative approaches. Here are the most common methods used by the community.

1. Manual Role Recreation

The simplest, though most tedious, method is to manually recreate each custom role on every subsite where it is needed. This ensures the role exists natively in each subsite's database. The key drawback is that any future changes to the role's capabilities must be manually repeated on every single subsite.

2. Using Custom Code or a Helper Plugin

For developers, writing custom code to copy roles from the main site to subsites is a popular solution. This typically involves using the get_option() function to retrieve the wp_user_roles array from the primary site and then using switch_to_blog() and update_option() to write it to each subsite.

Community Resource: Many users have found guidance on this approach from a WordPress Stack Exchange thread that discusses methods for copying roles in a Multisite environment.

3. Plugin Activation Strategy

How you activate the Members plugin can affect role management:

  • Network-Activated: The plugin is active on all subsites. Roles are still stored per-site, but the plugin's interface is available everywhere.
  • Per-Site Activation: The plugin is only active on subsites where you manually activate it. This can be useful if role management is only needed on specific sites.

There is no single "correct" method; the best choice depends on your specific network's needs. If issues arise, such as users not being assigned a role, test for conflicts by temporarily disabling other plugins, especially those that modify user management.

Conclusion

The behavior of roles in a WordPress Multisite is a design characteristic of WordPress itself, not a limitation of any specific role editing plugin. While the Members plugin provides a powerful interface for managing roles on individual sites, it does not include a feature to synchronize or network-manage roles across subsites. Understanding this fundamental separation of role data is the first step toward implementing an effective management strategy for your network, whether through manual processes, custom development, or careful plugin management.

Related Support Threads Support