BugWP logo BugWP
Back to Community
Home / Community / Plugin → Wp mail smtp by wpforms

Troubleshooting 'SMTP Error: Could Not Authenticate' in WP Mail SMTP

20 threads Sep 16, 2025 Plugin → Wp mail smtp by wpforms

Content

One of the most common errors encountered when configuring the 'WP Mail SMTP by WPForms' plugin is the frustrating SMTP Error: Could not authenticate message. This error halts form submissions, notification emails, and other critical site functions, leaving both site owners and their visitors in the lurch.

This guide will explain why this authentication error occurs and walk you through the most effective steps to resolve it, based on common solutions found in community support forums.

What Does This Error Mean?

The error SMTP Error: Could not authenticate is a clear signal that your WordPress site successfully initiated a connection to your chosen mail server (like Gmail, Outlook, your hosting provider's server, etc.), but it failed to log in. The server rejected the credentials provided, preventing the email from being sent.

Why Does the "Could Not Authenticate" Error Happen?

There are several potential root causes for this authentication failure:

  • Incorrect Login Credentials: This is the most frequent cause. A typo in the SMTP username, password, or API key will always result in a failed authentication attempt.
  • Outdated or Incomplete API Keys: For mailers like Sendinblue/Brevo, an API key that is old, revoked, or only partially copied can cause an "Unauthorized" or "Key not found" error, which manifests as an authentication failure.
  • Host Server Restrictions: Some web hosting providers block outgoing SMTP connections made through PHP for security reasons. If the connection is blocked entirely, you may not be able to authenticate.
  • Mail Server Security Policies: The mail service you are using (e.g., Gmail, Office 365) may have security settings like two-factor authentication that require an application-specific password, or it may be blocking login attempts from an unfamiliar location (your web server).

How to Fix the "Could Not Authenticate" Error

Follow these troubleshooting steps in order to diagnose and resolve the issue.

1. Double-Check Your SMTP Credentials

Carefully re-enter all your settings in the WP Mail SMTP plugin settings page. Pay close attention to:

  • SMTP Username: This is often your full email address.
  • SMTP Password: If you are using Gmail or a service with two-factor authentication, you likely need to generate and use an App Password, not your regular account password.
  • API Keys: If using an API-based mailer (like Sendinblue, MailerLite, or SendGrid), ensure you have copied the entire key from your account dashboard. It's good practice to delete the old key and generate a new one, then paste the complete new key into WP Mail SMTP.

2. Verify Your SMTP Host and Port Settings

An incorrect server hostname or port can prevent a proper connection. Confirm the correct SMTP host (e.g., smtp.gmail.com) and port (e.g., 465 for SSL, 587 for TLS) with your email service provider. Using the wrong port is a common mistake.

3. Contact Your Web Host

If you are certain your credentials are correct, the problem may lie with your web hosting environment. Contact your host's support team and ask them to:

  • Verify they do not block outgoing SMTP connections.
  • Check if any firewall or ModSecurity rules are interfering with the connection to your mail server.
  • Confirm that your server's PHP installation can establish external SMTP connections.

4. Consider Switching Mailers

The "Other SMTP" option can be tricky due to host restrictions and complex security settings on email accounts. Many community members have resolved persistent authentication issues by switching to a dedicated third-party mailer supported by the plugin, such as SendLayer, Brevo (formerly Sendinblue), or SendGrid. These services are designed for transactional email and often provide more reliable delivery and simpler setup within the plugin.

5. Confirm the Error Source

Before spending too much time troubleshooting, ensure the error is actually from WP Mail SMTP. Use the plugin's Email Test tool (found under WP Mail SMTP > Tools). If the test email sends successfully, the problem is likely not with your SMTP configuration but with the specific form or plugin that is trying to send the email. In this case, you should contact the support team for that specific form plugin.

By methodically working through these steps, you can identify the source of the authentication failure and get your WordPress site's emails sending reliably again.

Related Support Threads Support