BugWP logo BugWP
Back to Community
Home / Community / Plugin → Mc4wp: mailchimp for wordpress

Troubleshooting Mailchimp User Sync Issues in WordPress

24 threads Sep 9, 2025 Plugin → Mc4wp: mailchimp for wordpress

Content

If you're using the 'MC4WP: Mailchimp for WordPress' ecosystem to keep your WordPress users and Mailchimp audience in sync, you might have encountered some frustrating roadblocks. This guide covers the most common User Sync problems reported by users and provides clear steps to diagnose and resolve them.

Common User Sync Problems and Their Causes

Based on widespread community reports, these are the most frequent issues:

  • Sync Not Working for New Users: New WordPress users are not being added to the specified Mailchimp list.
  • "Member In Compliance State" Errors: Sync fails with errors mentioning a "compliance state," often related to GDPR settings or previous unsubscribes/bounces in Mailchimp.
  • Manual Sync Finds Users But Doesn't Process Them All: The sync log shows it found a large number of users (e.g., 114) but only processes a smaller batch (e.g., 100).
  • Custom Field Data Not Syncing Correctly: Data from WordPress user meta fields (like those from ACF) does not appear or update correctly in Mailchimp merge fields.
  • Legacy Plugin Confusion: Uncertainty around the discontinued free "User Sync" add-on versus the User Sync feature in the premium "MC4WP" plugin.

Step-by-Step Troubleshooting Guide

1. Verify Your Setup and Plugin Status

The first and most critical step is to identify which tool you are using for synchronization. The free "User Sync" add-on was officially discontinued and is no longer supported or updated. Its functionality, with significant improvements and changes, was integrated into the premium version of the "MC4WP" plugin. If you are relying on the old, unsupported add-on, many sync issues are expected and will likely not be resolved. Check your Plugins page in WordPress for "MC4WP User Sync" or "Mailchimp User Sync" and note its status.

2. Check the Debug Log

Both the old and current sync tools offer logging functionality. Enable debug logging from the MC4WP settings page (usually under "Other") and set it to "Log everything." Reproduce the issue by updating a user profile or running a manual sync. Then, check the log for specific error messages. An error like ERROR: User Sync > Error subscribing or updating user: Bad Request. Member In Compliance State points to a Mailchimp-side restriction, not a plugin bug.

3. Investigate Mailchimp Compliance Issues

The "Member In Compliance State" error means the email address exists in Mailchimp with a status of unsubscribed, cleaned, or pending a GDPR compliance review. Mailchimp's API prevents automatically re-adding these addresses to a list. You must manually address this in your Mailchimp audience dashboard by deleting the old member or ensuring your GDPR settings between WordPress and Mailchimp are aligned before syncing.

4. Review Custom Field Mapping

If custom user meta fields (like user roles or ACF fields) are not syncing correctly:

  • Ensure the field is created in your Mailchimp audience.
  • In the User Sync settings, click "Renew Mailchimp lists" to refresh the available merge tags.
  • Clear any WordPress caching (like WP Super Cache) that might be serving an old list of available fields.
  • Note that some complex WordPress data, like user capabilities, may not map directly to a text field and require a custom code snippet to transform the data first.

5. Understand Sync Limitations

The sync process may not subscribe new users if you are using the old, discontinued User Sync add-on, as this behavior was changed in its final versions. Furthermore, the sync is designed to update existing contacts on your list, not necessarily subscribe new ones or unsubscribe deleted ones, depending on your configuration. For adding new users, the "User Registration" integration is often the more reliable method.

When to Consider an Alternative Approach

Due to the complexities of two-way data synchronization and GDPR, many users find that a full, automatic sync creates more problems than it solves. A more stable approach is to use the plugin's form integrations (like for WooCommerce, BuddyPress, or WordPress user registration) to add subscribers at the point of sign-up. For existing user data, a manual export from WordPress and import into Mailchimp is often the most reliable method.

If you require advanced, automated syncing logic (like syncing only users with a specific Paid Memberships Pro membership status), you will likely need custom development work to extend the plugin's functionality with filters and custom code.

Remember, the 'MC4WP: Mailchimp for WordPress' team has stated that the old, free User Sync add-on is unsupported and may cause unexpected behavior. For issues with the User Sync feature within the premium plugin, you must contact the developer directly through their official channels.

Related Support Threads Support